Keffer Hirschauer Indiana Law Firm Logo
Close this search box.
Keffer Hirschauer Indiana Law Firm Logo
put short code to menu here

Share this Article

Share this Article >

What is a Consumer Protection Complaint in Indiana? 

In the bustling landscape of Indiana’s economy, where licensed professionals across various industries serve the needs of the Hoosier state, maintaining trust and integrity is paramount. Yet, there are moments when disputes arise, leading to consumer protection complaints. For licensed professionals, understanding what constitutes a consumer protection complaint in Indiana, and the process of litigating a complaint, is not just beneficial—it’s essential for safeguarding their careers and ensuring they can continue to serve their community effectively.  

Consumer protection complaints in Indiana can emerge from a myriad of situations—ranging from allegations of unfair business practices, breaches of contract, to professional misconduct that violates state regulations or industry standards. These complaints are not merely feedback; they are formal accusations that can trigger a series of legal responses, potentially culminating in the investigation and discipline of an Indiana professional license holder.  

Given the serious implications, it’s crucial for professionals to have a thorough understanding of what these complaints entail, the legal framework governing them, and the potential outcomes they may face. It’s also crucial that all licensed professionals understand that the best outcomes in situations like these are often secured with the help of an experienced Indiana professional license defense attorney. They’ll know how to best respond to consumer protection complaints, navigate the associated administrative procedures, and ultimately, how to craft an optimal defense strategy aimed at protecting the professional’s license, livelihood, and reputation.  

To begin addressing this consumer complaint today, contact the license defense attorneys at Keffer Hirschauer LLP at 317-751-7186 or complete our online contact form to schedule a free consultation. 

Indiana Professional License Defense Attorneys

Common Consumer Protection Complaints in Indiana 

In Indiana, as in many other states, licensed professionals across various fields may face consumer protection complaints for a number of reasons. These complaints typically revolve around issues that affect the consumer’s trust and safety, reflecting concerns over unethical, illegal, or unprofessional conduct. Understanding the most common types of these complaints can help professionals anticipate potential issues and implement practices to avoid them.  

Here’s an overview of the most common consumer protection complaints within the context of licensed professionals in Indiana

Misrepresentation or Fraud: This category includes complaints arising from professionals providing false, misleading, or deceptive information to consumers. It can range from false advertising of services, exaggeration of qualifications or results, to fraudulent billing practices. Misrepresentation is a serious accusation that can severely damage a professional’s reputation and the status of their professional licensure in Indiana

Breach of Contract: Complaints may also stem from allegations that a professional failed to deliver services as agreed upon in the contract. This can occur when a professional does not finish the agreed-upon work by the contract’s end date or within a reasonable timeframe. It may also occur when a professional’s services fall short of the quality or standards specified in the contract. This is especially common with professions like construction, healthcare, or legal services; where substandard quality can have severe repercussions, from physical risks to significant financial or emotional distress.  

Professional Negligence or Malpractice: Especially relevant to healthcare providers, engineers, and other professionals whose work directly impacts the physical well-being or safety of their clients, complaints of negligence or malpractice are serious. They involve allegations that the professional failed to meet the standard of care in their field, leading to harm or loss. 

Unlicensed Practice: Operating without a valid license constitutes a substantial problem in careers mandating state licensure. This dilemma encompasses not only individuals who engage in professional activities without ever securing a license but also includes professional licenses in Indiana that have lapsed or have been suspended or revoked. Engaging in professional practice without a valid license undermines the regulatory standards established to ensure public safety and professional competence. Moreover, professionals found to be operating without a valid license face significant legal consequences, including fines, penalties, and possibly criminal charges, depending on the severity of the violation.  

Violations of Privacy or Confidentiality: Particularly relevant in the fields of behavioral health, social work, and medical licensing —areas where maintaining confidentiality is of utmost importance—complaints often stem from accusations related to the mishandling or unauthorized release of personal or sensitive data. In these professions, the safeguarding of client or patient information is not merely a procedural duty; it is a foundational ethical obligation critical to the trust and integrity of the therapeutic or healthcare relationship. 

Unfair Billing Practices: This situation encompasses a variety of problematic practices, such as overbilling, charging for services that were not actually provided, or utilizing complex and unclear billing methods that can mislead or deceive consumers regarding the true costs of services. These practices not only represent a breach of ethical standards but also constitute a form of financial misconduct that can have significant implications for both service providers and consumers. 

Poor Quality of Service: Complaints can arise from perceptions of substandard service quality, encompassing situations where the service rendered failed to align with the client’s expectations or fell short of established industry benchmarks. These grievances may cover a broad spectrum of concerns, from the lack of thoroughness in the service delivery to outright negligence, leading to dissatisfaction and potential harm to the client. 

Failure to Communicate: A deficiency in communication or an inability to keep the consumer adequately informed about critical elements of the service—including potential risks, alternative options, or modifications in the method of service delivery—can be a significant source of complaints. This shortfall often stems from a failure to establish clear, open lines of communication between the service provider and the consumer, which is essential for fostering an environment of trust and mutual understanding. 

Discrimination or Bias: Allegations that services were denied or altered based on discriminatory practices related to race, gender, religion, or other protected characteristics can also be the basis for consumer protection complaints. These claims point to a serious breach of ethical and legal standards, indicating a failure to provide equitable service to all individuals regardless of their background. Discrimination in service provision violates individual rights and undermines the principles of fairness and equality foundational to consumer protection laws. Such practices can lead to a loss of trust in the service provider, potentially inviting legal action and damaging the provider’s reputation and relationship with the community. 

Ethics Violations: This expansive category encompasses a wide array of unethical behaviors that, while not directly related to the actual delivery of services, are critically important to maintaining professional conduct. It includes instances of conflicts of interest, where an individual’s personal interests might interfere with their professional responsibilities, bribery, which involves offering or receiving unearned rewards to influence behavior in a professional setting, and various other forms of corruption that undermine the integrity of professional practices. Such behaviors compromise the fairness and trustworthiness of professional environments, eroding public confidence and potentially causing significant harm to the reputation and operational capacity of the organization involved. 

Addressing these common complaints often requires a proactive approach, including maintaining transparent and honest communication with clients, adhering strictly to professional and ethical standards, and engaging in continuous professional development. For professionals facing such complaints, the Indianapolis professional license defense lawyers at Keffer Hirschauer LLP can provide critical guidance and support in navigating the complaint process and mitigating any potential threats to their professional license..  

The Process of Litigating a Complaint

Navigating the intricacies of a consumer complaint in Indiana can be a complex process, requiring a detailed understanding of the legal framework and procedural steps involved. For professionals facing such complaints, comprehending this process is crucial to effectively respond and protect their licenses and careers. This section outlines the typical journey of a consumer complaint in Indiana, from its inception to its resolution, offering insights into what licensed professionals can expect and how they can prepare. 

Step 1: Filing of the Complaint 

The process begins when a consumer files a complaint with the PLA or by completing an online consumer complaint form, a printable form, or a fillable online form on the Attorney General’s consumer complaint page. Complaints are usually submitted with comprehensive details of the allegations of misconduct or violation of consumer protection laws. 

Step 2: Written Notice and Initial Review 

Upon receiving a complaint, the Attorney General’s office must provide notice of the complaint to the license holder, who will in turn have the ability to file a written response. At the same time, the AG’s office will conduct an initial review to determine if the allegations warrant further investigation. This step involves assessing whether the complaint falls within the agency’s jurisdiction and if it contains credible allegations of legal or ethical violations. If the complaint is deemed insufficient or irrelevant, it may be dismissed at this stage.  

Step 3: Investigation 

If the regulatory body decides that the complaint merits further action, it will initiate a formal investigation in accordance with Indiana Code 25-1-7. This process may involve gathering documents, interviewing witnesses, and collecting other forms of evidence related to the complaint. As the investigation’s subject, the professional may be asked to respond to the allegations and any relevant information or documentation. 

Step 4: Review and Decision 

If, upon completion of the investigation, the AG’s office finds that the complaint has merit, they may elect to move the complaint to prosecution before the relevant board or commission. Alternatively, a license holder may also attempt to reach a settlement with the AG’s office. This is often done with the help of a Indiana professional license attorney with the stated goal of resolving the matter before it reaches the professional licensing board.  

Step 4: Prosecution 

Per Indiana Code 25-1-7-7, if a settlement is not reached, the AG’s office will refer the case to the relevant board, commission, or committee, which schedules a public evidentiary hearing. Again, the license holder may attempt to reach a settlement with their governing body prior to hearing. However, if one is not reached, the matter will proceed to an evidentiary hearing with either the entire board, commission, or committee or an administrative law judge serving as the fact finder (decision maker) in the case. 

These types of hearings typically operate in a similar manner to trial courts; complete with witnesses, cross-examinations, and arguments from both sides. Therefore, having an attorney with extensive experience by your side is crucial to secure the optimal outcome.  

At the conclusion of the hearing, the fact finder will determine whether any practical or ethical standards of your profession were violated, and if so, what disciplinary consequences shall be ordered. While the possible disciplinary sanctions vary depending on the board or commission involved, they generally include the suspension or revocation of the professional’s license; censure; reprimand; fines; or probationary status. Ultimately, if the professional is dissatisfied with the outcome, they may have the option to appeal the decision, seeking a review by a higher authority or court. 

Facing a Consumer Complaint in Indiana? 

Consumer protection laws are designed to safeguard the public from unfair, deceptive, and fraudulent business practices. While these regulations are crucial for maintaining trust and integrity within various industries, they can also be a source of significant anxiety for professionals accused of violations; especially if the allegation is unfairly made. Those faced with a consumer protection complaint in Indiana often feel confused about the process ahead of them and concerned about their future. That’s to be understood, especially with what’s at stake.  

At Keffer Hirschauer LLP, we understand the stress and uncertainty that accompany such complaints. Whether you’re a nurse, physical therapist, salon owner, or hold any other professional license, it’s essential to approach the situation with seriousness and precision. From gathering evidence to crafting a compelling defense, every action you take can significantly impact the outcome of your case. With the right approach and legal expertise on your side, it’s possible to address and resolve consumer protection complaints effectively, thus diffusing any potential threat to your professional license in Indiana and safeguarding your future. 

Article Name
What is a Consumer Protection Complaint in Indiana?
This article explains what a consumer protection complaint in Indiana is and the process of litigating one.
Publisher Name
Keffer Hirschauer LLP

Topic Categories

More Topics