Keffer Hirschauer Indiana Law Firm Logo
Free Consultation
Keffer Hirschauer Indiana Law Firm Logo

Meet Our Team

Home | Meet Our Indianapolis Attorneys | Peter Capofari

Peter Capofari

Attorney

Flyout Menu

When you’re facing criminal charges in Indiana, you need more than just legal representation—you need a fierce advocate with the skill to challenge the prosecution and the insight to anticipate its every move. Peter Capofari is that attorney. A veteran trial lawyer with a career spanning over 15 years in both prosecution and defense, Mr. Capofari brings a rare and invaluable perspective to every case he handles.

Peter Capofari has earned a reputation in Indiana courtrooms for delivering powerful results in high-stakes trials, including full acquittals in cases ranging from Operating a Vehicle While Intoxicated (OWI) to Attempted Murder. His career began in the trenches of prosecution, where he learned how cases are built, charged, and tried. Today, as a dedicated Indiana criminal defense lawyer, Mr. Capofari uses that knowledge to dismantle the State’s case and protect his clients’ futures—whether through aggressive litigation or strategic resolution.

Peter Capofari: Building a Trial‑Ready Foundation from Day One

Peter Capofari’s legal career was forged early through hands-on courtroom experience and a commitment to mastering the mechanics of criminal prosecution. As a scholarship recipient at St. Thomas University School of Law in Miami Gardens, Florida, he immersed himself in trial advocacy from the outset, focusing his legal education on real-world litigation rather than theory alone.

While still in law school, Mr. Capofari was selected to serve as a Certified Legal Intern with the Florida State Attorney’s Office, where he prosecuted criminal cases in both the 17th Judicial Circuit in Fort Lauderdale and the 12th Judicial Circuit in Bradenton. In these roles, he gained firsthand experience trying cases, examining witnesses, and making charging and sentencing recommendations—responsibilities typically reserved for seasoned prosecutors. This early exposure to the pressures and strategies of criminal litigation laid the groundwork for his success as a trial lawyer.

After earning his Juris Doctor, Mr. Capofari continued to sharpen his courtroom skills as a Deputy Prosecuting Attorney in Elkhart County and later Hendricks County, Indiana. There, he handled a wide range of criminal matters and built a reputation as a disciplined, prepared, and effective litigator. These years in prosecution provided Mr. Capofari with a deep understanding of how criminal cases are investigated, evaluated, and presented to juries—insight he now leverages to the benefit of his clients as one of the best defense lawyers in Indiana.

A Veteran Advocate in the Courtroom: Indiana Criminal Defense Lawyer Peter Capofari

After years of sharpening his trial skills as a prosecutor in multiple jurisdictions, Peter Capofari transitioned to private practice to pursue what had always been his ultimate goal: standing between the accused and the power of the State. Now practicing across Indiana, he uses his insider knowledge of prosecutorial strategy, coupled with his trial-tested instincts, to defend clients facing the full range of criminal charges.

From major felony trials to criminal misdemeanor allegations, Mr. Capofari has successfully represented individuals in both bench and jury trials throughout the state. His depth of litigation experience enables him to swiftly identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s case, develop smart and aggressive defense strategies, and deliver results when it matters most—at trial, during negotiation, or in pre-trial motions practice.

Mr. Capofari is particularly adept at handling cases with significant consequences: those that carry the risk of lengthy incarceration, lifetime stigma, or civil collateral effects like license suspension or loss of gun rights. He is often called upon to defend complex cases involving technical evidence, multiple witnesses, and procedural traps—scenarios where his prosecutorial experience becomes a powerful asset.

As an experienced criminal defense lawyer at Keffer Hirschauer LLP, Peter Capofari handles cases at both the trial and appellate levels, including:

Mr. Capofari’s experience as a former Deputy Prosecutor gives him uncommon insight into how charging decisions are made, how plea deals are constructed, and where prosecutors are most vulnerable in trial. This makes him especially effective in defending against habitual offender allegations, multiple-charge prosecutions, and serious felony counts where trial is inevitable.

Whether you’re facing your first criminal charge or are accused of serious crimes, Peter Capofari brings the courtroom firepower and the compassionate guidance clients need during some of the most difficult times of their lives.

Expungement Attorney Indiana Residents Trust for a True Second Chance

A criminal record can cast a long shadow over your life—even long after you’ve served your time or resolved your case. In Indiana, prior arrests, charges, or convictions can follow you into job interviews, rental applications, loan approvals, and even prevent you from restoring your civil rights. Fortunately, Indiana’s expungement laws, found under Indiana Code 35-38-9, give many Hoosiers the chance to leave that past behind.

As an experienced expungement attorney in Indiana, Peter Capofari helps clients navigate the legal path to a clean slate. With over 15 years in criminal law—including years spent prosecuting cases across Indiana—he understands how criminal records impact every aspect of your life. Mr. Capofari also knows exactly what it takes to remove those barriers and help you move forward.

Expungement in Indiana is a powerful legal remedy—but it isn’t automatic. The process involves strict statutory timelines, specific eligibility criteria, and precisely drafted filings. Mistakes can delay or even derail your petition. Whether you’re looking to expunge a misdemeanor, a felony, or multiple convictions, Peter Capofari ensures your case is approached with the attention to detail it deserves.

Mr. Capofari has helped clients across the state:

  • Sea records from past misdemeanor and felony convictions
  • Remove dismissed or non-conviction arrests from background checks
  • Regain firearm rights previously lost due to conviction
  • Restore their reputation and qualify for employment or housing opportunities

Peter Capofari’s approach is both meticulous and client-focused. He understands that behind every Indiana expungement petition is a real person with real goals—whether that’s securing a professional license, getting a promotion, or simply no longer being defined by a past mistake.

If you’re ready to move on with your life, don’t leave your second chance to chance. Work with an experienced Indiana expungement lawyer who knows the state’s expungement laws inside and out—and who’s committed to helping you reclaim your future. Call Keffer Hirschauer LLP at 317-648-9560 or complete our online contact form to see whether you qualify for criminal record expungement in Indiana and take the first step toward a clean record.

Compassionate and Strategic Indiana Family Law Representation: Peter Capofari

Legal matters involving family law in Indiana are some of the most emotionally charged and personally complex legal issues a person can face. Whether navigating divorce, child custody, or support disputes, you deserve an Indiana family law attorney who brings not just legal knowledge, but empathy, clarity, and strength to your case. With over 15 years of experience as a trial attorney, Peter Capofari offers clients across Indiana a steady hand and a strategic approach during difficult times.

Drawing from his extensive courtroom background in both prosecution and defense, Peter Capofari knows how to effectively advocate for his clients while maintaining a focus on resolution and long-term stability. He understands that family law isn’t just about legal outcomes—it’s about protecting your children, your property, and your peace of mind. At Keffer Hirschauer LLP, Mr. Capofari delivers personalized legal guidance designed to help families move forward with confidence.

  • Divorce– Providing compassionate, results-driven representation in contested and uncontested divorces.
  • High-Conflict Custody – Advocating for parenting plans that prioritize children’s best interests while protecting parental rights.
  • Child Support – Ensuring fair and accurate support arrangements aligned with Indiana’s guidelines.
  • Child Visitation – Structuring visitation schedules that foster meaningful relationships between parents and children.
  • Paternity – Helping establish legal parentage to protect both parental rights and child welfare.
  • Spousal Maintenance – Pursuing or defending fair support arrangements based on each party’s financial needs and contributions.
  • Contempt Proceedings – Taking legal action when one party fails to follow court-ordered obligations.
  • Legal Separation – Guiding clients through formal separations while preserving key legal rights and protections.
  • Prenuptial and Postnuptial Agreements – Crafting clear and enforceable agreements that provide certainty and security for both parties.
  • Relocation with Children – Addressing the legal and logistical challenges of relocating minor children under Indiana law.
  • Grandparent Visitation – Advocating for grandparents seeking to maintain meaningful relationships with their grandchildren.

While Peter Capofari’s courtroom experience makes him a formidable litigator when needed, he approaches family law cases with an eye toward practical, sustainable solutions—always striving to minimize conflict and maximize stability for his clients and their children. If you’re facing a family law issue and need clear guidance from a leading family lawyer in Indiana who listens, cares, and fights when it counts, Mr. Capofari is ready to help.

Indiana Criminal Defense Lawyer Peter Capofari: Experienced, Empathetic, and Results-Driven

Peter Capofari exemplifies what clients deserve in a high-level Indiana defense attorney:

  • Deep Experience in criminal law, including both prosecution and defense, across multiple jurisdictions
  • Exceptional Trial Skill earned through years of litigating complex criminal cases in Indiana courtrooms
  • Client-Centered Advocacy marked by empathy, responsiveness, and a commitment to individualized strategies
  • A Strong Legal Network backed by the accomplished attorneys and resources of Keffer Hirschauer LLP

Clients facing criminal charges, seeking criminal record expungement, or navigating difficult family law disputes trust Mr. Capofari for his balance of tenacity and compassion. He approaches every case with a clear goal: achieving the best possible outcome while ensuring clients feel heard, informed, and empowered throughout the process.

Whether you need fierce representation in a high-stakes felony trial, guidance through Indiana’s expungement process, or counsel in a sensitive custody matter, Pete Capofari stands ready to advocate for you with integrity and strength.

To schedule a consultation with Mr. Capofari, call Keffer Hirschauer LLP at (317) 648-9560 or fill out our online contact form.

Bar Admissions

Education

Past Legal Experience

Certified Legal Intern, Florida State Attorney’s Office